Are Rotated Vulaks Really Free?

[Baylan295]

Originally Posted by Perissh [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Because when 2 guilds team up, you cant say a single guild killed it. So if Rustle and Anon teamed up for a kill, you cant say that Rustle killed it because they couldn't do it on their own, the same thing for Anon.

You really don't think that makes sense?

This only makes sense if you are trying to trivialize the accomplishments of smaller guilds who cannot or do not regularly field 80+ person raid forces for top end content. I was there for the aforementioned Vulak kill. I helped kill Vulak. My guild was there. We got a clean FTE. The mob died. We got loot from Vulak. How does that jive with you saying we “can’t say PS (or AG) killed Vulak”?

The mob is dead and we did it. Period. You want to put an asterisk on it? Say we didn’t kill it solo? Go ahead, it’s true, but it’s rhetorically and logically unsound to say we didn’t or can’t do it just because we didn’t do it solo. It sounds a hell of a lot different to say “PS can’t say it killed Vulak” compared to “PS can’t say it killed Vulak solo.”