Reinforcements for the Tunarean Regiment

[Nybras]

I have attempted to turn in this quest 5 times, and regardless how I've done Part 2 Krofer consistently eats the Report.
I've allowed the 4 giants to despawn, the next attempt I had killed the giants,
the 3rd try i had a druid calm the giants which allowed me to tell them to Troop Attack when reaching their final destination,
based on a suggestion by someone who has completed the quest I then skipped Krofer and tried turning in the report to Hlesson, and
lastly as Raev said, I have completed this quest on Loraen. I just gave Krofer the mission report back immediately after triggering the giants.
My friend attempted to spawn the giants, kill Krofer, and turn in after he respawns. Going by the guide, and attempting other methods nothing is giving a positive result to resume the quest.

1)say i am prepared to krofer
note to drioc
note to krofer
2)giants spawn(you can follow them and wait for them to despawn you do not need to do the fight scene although you can) if you have a tracker wait till they drop off takes about 25min
3)note from krofer back to krofer
note to drioc
note to hlesson
4)kill pectas easy pull to the icewell zoneline-get key
tablet from hlesson to corruduth on south shore under ice in IC
5)kill inco spirit on 6th floor tofs(abrams may spawn its about 50%)respawn is 45min-2.5hrs
beard from coruduth to abrams
6)give key and arcanum to hlesson, recieve voucher
tanks give to kellek
healers to wenglecks
casters back to hlesson
recieve presents and nobles seal