The Real Problem with Red!

[Derubael]

Nihilum took a huge penalty beyond having their guild leader and all of his characters banned. Ultimately it just didn't make sense to completely disband Nihilum for the reasons I stated in my quote in the OP. Nor did slapping Nizzar with the "permaban" label, again, for reasons stated above. The only hard evidence we had was the RMT - beyond that I have nothing that would stick. And because Nizzar was instrumental in another case I had, we let him stick around.

And in any case, ya'll dirty as fawk. Neither guild has a clean whistle, period, and if we held Red guilds to the same standard we hold the Blue guilds it'd be a much more sparsely populated box.