A bunch of people giving anecdotal evidence is still anecdotal evidence, just a lot of it. I'm sure a lot of people are complaining, but if you've played on p99 blue you'll also know that a lot of people think they know a lot more about playing this game than they actually do.
As for why a warrior would keep a primal in offhand, unless they didn't have a better procing weapon there really is no reason to keep in primal after it procs. Maybe if they're not tanking as well to avoid pulling aggro, but as a main tank is simply doesn't make sense to tank with a primal. Again though, just because you saw someone you thought was good at this game doing something on live, doesn't mean that was actually correct. As I said before, I was in a top end guild and back then I was straight awful at this game. The skill and knowledge level on live is no where near what it is on p99, even at the highest levels of play.
|