Bumamgar

[Chicka]

Originally Posted by Loke [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I just want to point out that the player created rules were quoted by GMs as justification for banning of certain members of Dark Ascension. Either enforce them, or don't - but to use them against DA and let WI slide in this instance doesn't semm right.

Bum, since you were asking about a source for whether or not GMs enforce them, there it is. The 2 golems in 50 minutes was cited a number of times by Cyrius as to why DA engaging Cazic Thule made him a contested mob, thus leading to the ban of two individuals.

Loke, you must know that is not the whole story, or maybe you don't.

First, you killed Draco, it was your mob after you had failed the 50 min timer on Inny, all good, but then you steamrolled into Inny too after IB had downed the golems and now had claim and needed to clear fear. But of course you, AS A RAID, knew you didn't have to clear fear because your guild leader (dressed as one of his alt accounts - winterfresh) and at least one officer rounded up the fear mobs that came to his aid and trained IB with them as we were clearing - the supporting screenshots almost certainly secured those two bans, no player made rules necessary. And you, AS A RAID, knew you did not have rights to both mobs. Frankly I think you got off lightly as a guild, even in retrospect. I don't know how you got 40-50 people or whatever you had to follow that path - they couldn't have all been ignorant of what was going on.

The big difference between that BS, and what happened with WI is that, whether you like it or not, IB chose not to enforce their rights in the situation, and therefore no rule was broken, player made or otherwise.