A Shady Goblin (Ring Roll) in Warsilk Woods

[Sadiki]

Originally Posted by azeth [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

...creates a rabbit hole argument.

Player made is player made. if someone fucks up, then its their reputation thats damaged.

Except it just comes to the forums as a bunch of lies and arguing anyways. Just mandate a roll officially and avoid all that. It's silly to avoid implementing a rule that already has a precedent and reduces toxicity just because of some hypothetical stuff. It's the better solution, proposed by people who don't want to cheat and argue.

What even is a damaged reputation on P99? Isn't success here directly proportional to how terrible of a person you are?

Originally Posted by azeth [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

the community is the problem

This isn't wrong, but what is the community going to do? Toxic_Player can run around and do this stuff all day with no repercussions. Community can't make it a roll because of Toxic_Player, community can get physically trolled by Toxic_Player, and they still get to show up and do it the next day. Rules, unfortunately, are needed in 2019-era EQ because everyone sucks.