New (old school) opinion

[mr.miketastic]

Originally Posted by Yukface [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I didnt make this an RnF, you guys did, I was just trying to let the management know that, as a "classic" player, who has been here a month, my short term impression was...the camp rules are bogus. And any "classic" player that ever had an epic pre-prepop, would agree. And, finally imho, those rules will dictate a playerbase that leaves shortly after realizing the only way they will have a anything close to a classic experience is if the first 200 players on the server decide to all quit , because the rules are clearly here to accommodate them. And again, like i said in my original post if you bothered to read it before you turned on your pilot light. My opinion can be and probably is wrong in some cases but perception is reality for me and most other new players who come here. Finally, to be frank, Rogean is probably perfectly happy with 500 player average, and if so good for him, keep on trucking.
If he wants my opinion, I gave it to him, and yes i know opinions are like assholes, everyone has one. I just like to flaunt mine.

Opinions are like assholes; Everyone has one and most of them stink.

[Yukface]

Originally Posted by mr.miketastic [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Opinions are like assholes; Everyone has one and most of them stink.

keep em coming...
You have gotten better at posting (2)
You have lost a level in trolling (-1)

[mr.miketastic]

Originally Posted by Yukface [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

keep em coming...
You have gotten better at posting (2)
You have lost a level in trolling (-1)

You should have really named your toon Ironybot.

[Bruman]

Originally Posted by Alawen Everywhere [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

They made up all kinds of weird stories to explain why it was unfair (GMs told IB when the spawns would be, third party software, psychic powers, you name it).

Originally Posted by Aeolwind [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I've actually heard enough of GM Favoritism for the last god damn time. Can it Alawen.

Alawen said it was a made up story, not saying it was real...I'm confused at the anger.

[Alawen Everywhere]

Originally Posted by TheDudeAbides [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

You guys were exploiting leatherfoot caps

Here are some things for you to think about:

Druids and wizards can port to West Commons.
Any caster can bind in West Commons.
Any melee character can get a port to West Commons.
Melee characters aren't the best farmers.
Caps are convenient, but they're expensive and unnecessary.
Farming plat for bandaids is inferior to just playing well in the first place.
Maybe you're nowhere near as good at playing EQ as you think you are.

[Alleusion]

Originally Posted by Yukface [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

GM's only intervened (immediately) on guild contested mobs, and rarely was the intervention, or abitration as they so eloquently call it anything more than a GL dice roll.

I don't know. I distinctly remember kicking an entire guild out of Ssra temple one night when they wouldn't honor the decision made. Punted each and every single one of them to their bind point so I could sit in Ssra and watch the guild that "won" the disagreement attempt their named ring. If they failed then I was fully prepared to summon every single player I punted so they could have their turn. I'm sure the wonderful players of Saryrn had many fine tales to tell of me after that night.

Bottom line is...this is not live. It is not run by Smedley. There is no Brenlo. You play by the rules given out by the developers and powers that be here. Rules on live don't necessarily transfer over to p1999.

[mr.miketastic]

Originally Posted by Alleusion [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I don't know. I distinctly remember kicking an entire guild out of Ssra temple one night when they wouldn't honor the decision made. Punted each and every single one of them to their bind point so I could sit in Ssra and watch the guild that "won" the disagreement attempt their named ring. If they failed then I was fully prepared to summon every single player I punted so they could have their turn. I'm sure the wonderful players of Saryrn had many fine tales to tell of me after that night.

Bottom line is...this is not live. It is not run by Smedley. There is no Brenlo. You play by the rules given out by the developers and powers that be here. Rules on live don't necessarily transfer over to p1999.

I would say that ^ has effectively ended the discussion.

[Alawen Everywhere]

Originally Posted by Aeolwind [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I've actually heard enough of GM Favoritism for the last god damn time. Can it Alawen.

Somehow I missed this post. I apologize if my sarcasm came off as offensive. I have no complaints about how the staff handles things.

My sincere personal opinion is that /petition should only be used for bugs or exploits. Whenever two raid forces escalate a dispute to require GM intervention, I consider it a failure of the leaders of those guilds. If server policy were up to me, I'd despawn a lot of bosses and hand out a lot of one day suspensions until the kids learned to play nice.

Then again, you guys run a successful server and I don't, so the value of my opinion is the same as any of the other blowhards on R&F.

[Yukface]

Originally Posted by mr.miketastic [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I would say that ^ has effectively ended the discussion.

I would say, stop posting in my thread cuz your a dumbass.

Originally Posted by Alleusion [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I don't know. I distinctly remember kicking an entire guild out of Ssra temple one night when they wouldn't honor the decision made. Punted each and every single one of them to their bind point so I could sit in Ssra and watch the guild that "won" the disagreement attempt their named ring. If they failed then I was fully prepared to summon every single player I punted so they could have their turn. I'm sure the wonderful players of Saryrn had many fine tales to tell of me after that night.

Bottom line is...this is not live. It is not run by Smedley. There is no Brenlo. You play by the rules given out by the developers and powers that be here. Rules on live don't necessarily transfer over to p1999.

Maybe you failed the recognize the word RARELY in my post. You mention the rare occasion where after the "dice roll" or whatever method you used to decide who would try "first" (I can guarantee it wasnt the guild who had 15 afk people sitting in the zone for 4 days, which btw is the point of my thread) the guild rebelled against you, yes, according to the rules you could and apparently did take action against those people and that was fine. AGAIN, I am not recommending anything other than allowing that competition to develop. ADMIT, that memory of that day was probably one of the few things all those players remember about their experience, obviously you do, which is my point.

Mr. Mikenoobtastic please stfu....you are a level 10 noob with like 20 posts... go level or do what I am doing voice your opinion about the game, your BS in this thread is not needed or desired.

[Taxi]

My god aoelwind, stop closing these huge pointless threads, its just gonna spill over to any other threads, at least contain it in one huge thread.