Are we allowed to like AI art?

[Duik]

Simply put.
Fuck A.I and by extension robotics that use it.
They said it would mow my lawns and do my washing up. Or dangerous mining jobs on titan.

Instead it needs to "borrow" from real artists so it can survive. I say fucking die cold and hungry, like real artists can and do.
Defo not defending Disney here, they suck too and fuck good franchises. But individual artists cant sue large A.I corps so Im good with Disney doing that dirty work.

Sorry (you may not) got A.I to draw hot elf titties.

[Swish]

Originally Posted by shovelquest [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

This could mean the end of generative AI (In the west).

Disney Vs Midjourney Round 1: FIGHT!

It'll go either the way of online poker or torrents at worst. You can still find such things but there'll be a bit of a frown legally.

[shovelquest]

Originally Posted by Duik [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Simply put.
Fuck A.I and by extension robotics that use it.
They said it would mow my lawns and do my washing up. Or dangerous mining jobs on titan.

Instead it needs to "borrow" from real artists so it can survive. I say fucking die cold and hungry, like real artists can and do.
Defo not defending Disney here, they suck too and fuck good franchises. But individual artists cant sue large A.I corps so Im good with Disney doing that dirty work.

Sorry (you may not) got A.I to draw hot elf titties.

Someone's having their period.

[Reiwa]

Originally Posted by shovelquest [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

This could mean the end of generative AI (In the west).

Disney Vs Midjourney Round 1: FIGHT!

Personally I think what we're seeing here is tantamount to suing Adobe for users creating images with copywritten characters.

Disney should sue an individual from making money with a copywritten character not the tool they used to make it.

If MJ pays a license to Disney, then they have to for everyone and they shut down.

If they cant use Disney, then they cant use anyone, shut down.

I see no way forward for generative AI if Disney wins this.

I'm split on it, because I don't think generative AI is essential for AI to develop, and I may prefer that instead of these programmers working on generative AI they work on a better calendar or Email system or something for me to use.

But on the other hand, I think the law that exists today covers this, and MJ is free from blame for what its users create. And we should see just how far this rabbit hole goes.

Disney should be suing anyone who publishes a image of one of thier characters, and that's my take.

It'd be like DBG shutting down EQEMU and all emu's because THJ blew up and made money. Targeting THJ is the right call there, while targeting Midjourney is the wrong call with this disney thing.

I wonder what the courts will decide! I feel like we're at a crossroads for generative AI! (In the west - China and Russia will take over the entertainment industry)

It scares me a little bit, to like, stop technological progress out of fear of anything, especially Disney's franchises.

Makes me feel like earth has reached "europe" phase, where we just sit around dumping shit out of windows for like 500 years.

Haven't clicked the video yet but it sounds like a battle of license terms? MJ probably asserts rights to own whatever is created with it. Conflicts with Disney prior ownership of cartoon meeses extant.

[Reiwa]

[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[shovelquest]

Originally Posted by Reiwa [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Haven't clicked the video yet but it sounds like a battle of license terms? MJ probably asserts rights to own whatever is created with it. Conflicts with Disney prior ownership of cartoon meeses extant.

Yeah this is about the "act" of creating copywritten characters, not reproducing and distributing copywritten material.

I really hate how the current law already protects Disney, but they just don't want people "doing the thing".

It's a scary precedent because that means there's a lot we "could do" that we wont be allowed to do as 2nd class (standard) citizens.

Also it's dangerous IMO for misinformation, to make humans think that AI art doesn't exist by shutting down the tools to use it. So bad actors can use it, and people will be more inclined to think it's real.

I see this as 2 paths we can take.

One, is the path theocracies and other dictatorships take. The other is the one that led to America, and freedom.

[shovelquest]

Look what I did with MS paint! Time to sue microsoft (and P99 for hosting this image).

[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[magnetaress]

Disney is the beast.

[shovelquest]

Originally Posted by magnetaress [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Disney is the beast.

The fact that in the video, 9/10 images they show are characters that were NOT created by Disney is really funny to me.

This isnt about artists, or their creations.. Its about Disney buying those creations, and not allowing artists or creators to ever talk about or use them lol.

Compare this to the THJ situation.

THJ is in trouble because they did publish and profit off of copywritten material.

But should Disney sue Microsoft, because THJ used a windows computer to mod the game?

Should we get rid of the copy and paste tool on computers because some people us it to copy and paste copywritten characters?

[magnetaress]

Originally Posted by shovelquest [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

The fact that in the video, 9/10 images they show are characters that were NOT created by Disney is really funny to me.

This isnt about artists, or their creations.. Its about Disney buying those creations, and not allowing artists or creators to ever talk about or use them lol.

Compare this to the THJ situation.

THJ is in trouble because they did publish and profit off of copywritten material.

But should Disney sue Microsoft, because THJ used a windows computer to mod the game?

Should we get rid of the copy and paste tool on computers because some people us it to copy and paste copywritten characters?

Disney says yes. Notice TV apps don't have copy paste and it's more obscured on mobile OS platforms. My android lost the ability to directly upload to imgur temporarily. And now the URL links are obfuscated. Look at the defunct flash API.

The water is slowly boiling and the frogs are gonna be dead.