list system flaw

[Grakken]

Originally Posted by Rang [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

List system is a socialism pilot program study being performed by the NSA and CIA and you are all the lab rats. They are ironing out the details to apply the /list command to all things in RL.

[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[Gustoo]

Originally Posted by Donkey Hotay [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Four people are refusing to cooperate to get pixels in an MMO.

The list system isn't broken. The players are.

QFT.

Buncha psychos won't kill a mob to better a rogue and themselves because the rogue can't solo the mob.

If I was the rogue I would call in sick from work for days just to spite you psychopaths.

[bubur]

when it comes to manastone id help to move along if it isnt a bunch of afk'ers

rubi bp and even guise, my lv 50 can die doing if someone messes up the room break. id rather just solo it, which i can do in the off hours when there are 0 list on teal

not sure how it is on green tho. just join a guild and ask them to help if you're in the same position as this rogue. its your own risk if you want to sit on /list at spot #1 and no one wants to put their neck out for spot 2 or 3. i also dont think he should be bullied off of spot #1, but that's the empasse

the only solution, as always, is to log out

[Tilien]

Originally Posted by bubur [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

the only solution, as always, is to log out

This was always the solution to any problem in EQ, but few people take that option and most make the mistake of logging back on.

[Jack N]

Heaven forbid we have the requirement that someone claiming a camp actually be able to hold it. Maybe I can sit outside of Lguk Lord room on my solo hidden rogue and claim the camp until someone else comes along and clears it, then claim they KSed me.

[Tilien]

Originally Posted by Jack N [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Heaven forbid we have the requirement that someone claiming a camp actually be able to hold it. Maybe I can sit outside of Lguk Lord room on my solo hidden rogue and claim the camp until someone else comes along and clears it, then claim they KSed me.

List =/= camp. If someone is camping a room for xp and non list item loot then the listers would technically not be able to kill the room pops unless the campers lost the room.

Hence why you could charm the list mob to use as a pet to farm the non list mobs in or near the camp if it isn't being cleared. If anyone killed it during a charm break they'd be ksing you, even if you're not on the list.

[Grakken]

Originally Posted by Jack N [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Heaven forbid we have the requirement that someone claiming a camp actually be able to hold it. Maybe I can sit outside of Lguk Lord room on my solo hidden rogue and claim the camp until someone else comes along and clears it, then claim they KSed me.

I agree. But, now you've queued the automated response from people feeling compelled to correct you that list and camps have nothing to do with each other. Its the most eye rolling clarification.

[Jack N]

Originally Posted by Tilien [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

List =/= camp. If someone is camping a room for xp and non list item loot then the listers would technically not be able to kill the room pops unless the campers lost the room.

Hence why you could charm the list mob to use as a pet to farm the non list mobs in or near the camp if it isn't being cleared. If anyone killed it during a charm break they'd be ksing you, even if you're not on the list.

That is your convenient interpretation.

[Deckk]

So if you play a class that can't solo him, that can use the BP, you shouldn't have a shot at it... But the person who plays a class that can't use the BP, but can solo it, should?

I fully admit that reading is hard and I could have missed something... or maybe the OP is a shaman or something like that!

[Tilien]

Originally Posted by Deckk [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

So if you play a class that can't solo him, that can use the BP, you shouldn't have a shot at it... But the person who plays a class that can't use the BP, but can solo it, should?

I fully admit that reading is hard and I could have missed something... or maybe the OP is a shaman or something like that!

Everyone can use it in the EC tunnel in 2 years.