shit's goin down!

[Estolcles]

Originally Posted by Alarti0001 [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I have 13 total raid related petitions.... you really shouldnt make claims I can easily... prove.

Elipses prove guilt.

[Ravager]

Originally Posted by Alarti0001 [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

We might have allowed someone else to loot the item.. however anthrax took that choice from us. We often open up loot to whomever is in zone. Sorry buddy the facts don't support your statement.

In those days you opened it up to whomever had 250k to spend on rots. Not arguing about the ninja looting, though the version of events I always heard was Anthrax was baited into looting it.

[Rais]

So you made 13 shitty raid petitions your own guild leader didn't want you to make and finally forced you to quit after the staff told him to. This isn't including in game petitions either.

Thank you for proving me correct.

[Alarti0001]

Originally Posted by Ravager [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

In those days you opened it up to whomever had 250k to spend on rots. Not arguing about the ninja looting, though the version of events I always heard was Anthrax was baited into looting it.

Would love to see this transcript. Little chance that happened but I would love to see Anthrax's defense.

[Alarti0001]

Originally Posted by Rais [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

So you made 13 shitty raid petitions your own guild leader didn't want you to make and finally forced you to quit after the staff told him to. This isn't including in game petitions either.

Thank you for proving me correct.

Except 13 isn't anywhere close to "more than anyone else" and most of those were at his express instruction... since he was busy with other things, and I had a fairly high success rate.

[drdrakes]

Where else are ~7 people arguing this passionately about something that means so little? This shit is amazing, I bet you are all >25 too.

[Alarti0001]

Originally Posted by drdrakes [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Where else are ~7 people arguing this passionately about something that means so little? This shit is amazing, I bet you are all >25 too.

Passion dies at 25? Your love life must be very boring.

[Rais]

It's people bored doing work or homework bro. Not many people really take this serious.

[Rattle Squirrell]

This is moderately entertaining to see a bunch of neck-beards fighting over "raid rules".

bahaha

[Troubled]

Originally Posted by ssfarmer [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

/sigh

what i dont understand is that IB trains TMO @ naggy and causes wipe..... which causes tmo's aggro to transfer and pull naggy out of lair.... tmo conceded because this is against the rules on our part - imo issue solved ib gets an uncontested naggy

again at trak tmo engages too soon, tmo makes no other attempt other than CRing (even CR and buffed some taken who died when the repop happened) and was almost compeltey full buffed and more than ready to engage a 2nd time before ib goes in..... yet tmo stays back conceding mob (was an argument about this i will say, but no attempt to pull was made) again, ib gets uncontested trakanon while TMO CRs itself + taken people- issue should be resolved

IB has a history of having mobs conceded to them and then bitching to staff about the issue getting 2x the rewards, yet when they are in the wrong they wont do the same thing.... we all thought that arguments were supposed to be worked out between guilds first and tmo is willing but ib wont, i mean just look at them training hoshkar on tmo causing a wipe and then going and killing the mob themselves this past week + dropping hoshkar into our pull (as lazie has shown they used this as a defense to cause a suspension against tmo) yet think its perfectly fine.

To derubael's post:

how bout that rule being posted? why are none of the rulings EVER posted..... are we supposed to just remember every single ruling ever handed down? and why has this never been enforced? its been done on both sides plenty of times since you become a guide and NO punishment has EVER come from it.... i mean i have plenty of fraps of IB doing while i was raiding with them, and its happened a few times since i've been with tmo.... this has NEVER resulted in a punishment.

Can we please at least be consistent with rulings? instead of one week it be one thing and the next week it be something else? this has been an issue for as long as i've raided..... just clearly define situations and make a FAQ and put in raid discussion as a sticky then at least its posted (and this can be updated with each new ruling if something isnt clear about previous rulings) this might have an upfront time cost (minimal considering the time you already spend on things) and should save you plenty in the long run.... and it should stop most arguments

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLLLLLLL