Inny FTE rules clarification

[Metallikus]

Sirken announced TMO had FTE and loot rights to Inny. The logs showed crazyeyes as first to agro on the encounter log. That would obviously be enough to satisfy the raiders as FTE has been the rule. But afterwards Sirken joins guildchat and makes claims to counter his ruling by saying Inny is not first to agro but rather first to damage? What is up with that? Does anyone know the actual rules to raiding anymore?

logs of Sirken in guild chat trying to explain the FTE ruling for 1/4/3 Inny kill:

[Fri Jan 04 20:54:24 2013] Sirken tells the guild, 'GM Sirken here'
[Fri Jan 04 20:54:40 2013] Sirken tells the guild, 'I dont want to explain the same things 100x, so here goes'
[Fri Jan 04 20:55:02 2013] Sirken tells the guild, 'Different mobs = different situations'
[Fri Jan 04 20:55:23 2013] Sirken tells the guild, 'People pull inny to ent. whereas every sits on trak spawn spot for ft '
[Fri Jan 04 20:55:38 2013] Sirken tells the guild, 'So thats why dam is required for inny and not trak'
[Fri Jan 04 20:55:58 2013] Sirken tells the guild, 'Theres no conspiracy, its common sense based on what we can see in the logs'

[quido]

What about a miss?

[Relapse2]

it is 2013 can we stop crying about stupid mobs everyone has killed over 2 million times?

[Loly Taa]

Originally Posted by Relapse2 [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

it is 2013 can we stop crying about stupid mobs everyone has killed over 2 million times?

I think I have to agree with this man here.

[Bushido]

it is that way because because of past rulings. in the past 2 guilds were competing for inny. person1 agros inny and gets DT, person2 was the next to agro. person2's guild was the FTE by the ruling as inny reset(albeit for probably 1 millisecond). both guilds were right on inny's spawn waiting for him. i don't know this particular situation but it sounds like this is maybe what happened?

edit: nm had the wrong idea, but sirken sounds correct in his ruling given the situation.

[quido]

It's 2013, can we stop being inbred and crying about people crying over a game that we don't even play any more?

[Relapse2]

who says i don't play?

[Itap]

This make complete sense, how are you not understanding?

[Eccezan]

Originally Posted by quido [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

It's 2013, can we stop being inbred and crying about people crying over a game that we don't even play any more?

Hey whats this about not being inbred anymore?!?

"I'll tell you what. I'm going to give you a present. After I raise my armies, and kill your traitor brother, I'll give you his head as well. " - King Joffrey Baratheon, King of the Andals, the Rhoynar, and the First Men

[Metallikus]

What is the purpose of the additional Sirken babble in our guildchat about Trakanon FTE and INNY FTE being different? What is this "new rule" about first to damage? Please explain this.