Quest Issue: Robe of the Whistling Fists Quest . turn in to Brother Balatin Broken

[the_coyote]

One of the 3 items required for the "Robe of the Whistling Fists" is no longer recognized by Brother Balatin (in Dreadland).

Had a guildy do the turn in Twice this week :
First was a MQ that im 100% sure was done correctly Where Brother Balatin was charmed , handed the chardok pipe , then handed the Karnor pipe and the robe. He said 2 lines confirming he recieved at least 2 correct items , and then nothing , he didnt depop , and no reward.
Second time all the items where on the monk and did the sneak turn in method, Brother Balatin was indifferent during turn in, again ,he said 2 lines confirming he recieved at least 2 correct items , and then nothing , he didnt depop , and no reward.

I'm pretty sure the quest is broken. Can someone look into it and confirm ?