Confusion over which quests lower Rogues of the White Rose faction

[Wizardling]

Can anyone specify which of the quests in Halas and Everfrost actually have negative hits to the Barbarian Rogues of the White Rose faction? There seems to be a lot of conflicting info. One general guildline I read says only Shaman quests don't lower rogue faction in Halas. But the individual pages in the wiki and on ZAM give conflicting accounts.

Can anyone help clarify the situation, please? I don't want to ruin faction on my new barbarian rogue, and have to work for ages to repair it.

[Whirled]

http://wiki.project1999.com/Rogues_of_the_White_Rose

http://wiki.project1999.com/Mammoth_Calf_Hides

Hope this helps ~

[Wizardling]

Ok, but it's not very specific, and there's still confusion in comments on these quests. For example: the wiki pages suggests only Shaman quests will avoid negative faction hits to the rogues. But is that quests with positive shaman faction results, or only those give by actual shaman faction members? And are there truly no others outside of the rogue and shaman faction quests that won't result in negative faction hits for rogues in Halas?

[Whirled]

I do not know much of Halas aside from my faction is KoS. The wiki is not flawless so you may have to do a test quest or 3 to figure the best one or ask a barbarian rogue what they remember.

[Thulack]

yes the only 2 quests you can do to raise your faction are the mammoth calves and gnoll fur ones or kill Frostbite in WK. Thats it. Honestly the game is called Everquest but quests for the most part suck in the game. Just go grind levels and work on needed quests here and there. Once your higher level you will never goto halas again anyway so faction not a huge deal.

[Wizardling]

Yeah, I know there are only two quests that raise my faction. But as I said in my OP - I'm concerned over warnings in both the wiki and on ZAM about getting negative faction from all quests in Halas but shaman ones (which is still not very specific - see above).

[Thulack]

Originally Posted by Wizardling [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Yeah, I know there are only two quests that raise my faction. But as I said in my OP - I'm concerned over warnings in both the wiki and on ZAM about getting negative faction from all quests in Halas but shaman ones (which is still not very specific - see above).

Have you actually looked at the quests you want to do instead of just reading one line at the top of the page? There are only about 14 quests in Halas total. 2 to raise and only 2 i see that lower it. If you actually look at the quests on wiki or alla's it will tell you what factions are raised and lowered. This isnt rocket science. If it doesnt list a faction then try the quest and see. Your not going to go KoS from doing 1 handin.

[Wizardling]

Again I refer you to what I've already said. If my wanting to avoid remedial faction work due to unclear information - and it is unclear, if you bother to read more than just that single page (irony given you try to make out I'm the one who hasn't done his reading - funny how people who claim that are always the ones themselves who haven't) - troubles you, simply do not answer.

[Thulack]

Originally Posted by Wizardling [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Again I refer you to what I've already said. If my wanting to avoid remedial faction work due to unclear information - and it is unclear, if you bother to read more than just that single page (irony given you try to make out I'm the one who hasn't done his reading - funny how people who claim that are always the ones themselves who haven't) - troubles you, simply do not answer.

If you go here: http://wiki.project1999.com/Halas

and scroll down to the quests section and then actually click on a few of the quests you will see that not all of them give negative faction hit to white rose( the 3 i actually looked at didnt give any neg hits period). If that info is not good enough for you then as i said go do them yourself.

Edit:
http://wiki.project1999.com/The_Vengeful_Musicians (no faction hit)
http://wiki.project1999.com/Lion_Meat_Shipment_Quest ( No faction hit)
http://wiki.project1999.com/Magic_El...r_the_Warriors ( no faction hit)

want me to keep going?

And if 1 page says 1 thing and another page says another you know what you do......................the quest to find out which one is telling the truth cause honestly no one here on the forums seems to care enough to answer your question other then me for whatever reason.