In South Kaladim, 
Hanamaf Darkfoam is currently selling the following brewing items out of era:
- Barley
- Hops
- Malt
- Rice
- Wine Yeast
- Yeast
He doesn't appear to offer these items until the beginning of GoD. (See EQTraders: 
Dec2003 vs 
Feb2004)
In fact, somewhat surprisingly, there wasn't a brewing supply vendor offering the above ingredients in all of Faydwer until September 2000.
- 
https://groups.google.com/g/alt.game...m/6mLG01Q1-6EJ
	Quote:
	
	
		
			
				Bill Byrd 
Sep 13, 1999, 7:00:00 AM 
 
Are there ANY brewing supplies to be bought in Butcher or Kaladim? I 
think I've hit every merchant in the zones but have yet to see hops and 
barley and such anywhere. 
 
Dorfs not makin' beer? C'mon....
			
		 | 
	
	
 
	Quote:
	
	
		
			
				Cherubae 
Sep 14, 1999, 7:00:00 AM 
 
Nope, no brewing supplies in Kaladim, Kelethin, Ak'Anon, or Felwith. 
Travel to Freeport.
			
		 | 
	
	
 - 
https://web.archive.org/web/20001117...ps/vendors.htm
	Quote:
	
	
		| 
			
				If you look closely, there are NO specialty vendors in Brewing in all of Faydwer. So, brewing is a bit harder there, you'll need to travel to Freeport to get supplies.
			
		 | 
	
	
 - 
https://web.archive.org/web/20010306...de/brewing.htm
	Quote:
	
	
		
			
				... 
現在わかっている中で醸造のレシピ本は2冊。 
一冊はKaladimのアリーナ近くの酒場で売っています。 
もっともなぜこの近く(どころかFaydwer全体)にHopsなどの材料がないのかは謎です  。 
... 
 
From Google Translate: 
There are currently two brewing recipe books that I am aware of. One book is sold in a tavern near the arena in Kaladim. However, it is a mystery why there are no materials such as Hops in this vicinity (or even Faydwer as a whole).
			
		 | 
	
	
 A request is made:
- 
https://web.archive.org/web/20010429...p?Article=2516
	Quote:
	
	
		
			
				YAKATIZMA CHAT COMPLETED, SEPTEMBER 15, 2000 
 
Brodder_FoamyMu: Hoi Yak 
Brodder_FoamyMu: We talked the other night about brewing 
Brodder_FoamyMu: new recipe's and such 
  
Yakatizma: Aye 
  
Brodder_FoamyMu: but on faydwer there is a lack of brewing ingredients 
Brodder_FoamyMu: like mining the dwarves are supposed to be some of the best brewers in the lands 
Brodder_FoamyMu: will Faydwer receive supplies of brewing goods? 
Brodder_FoamyMu: and can you drop some hints into the Brewing of the Coldain, stormgiants and otehr new races of Velious:? 
Brodder_FoamyMu: done 
  
Yakatizma: I've added several recipes that require things that can be easily foraged in Faydwer, I've heard that some basic brewing vendors are lacking ingredients for the old brews though? 
  
Brodder_FoamyMu: yes there is no hops, malt barley rice or yeast for wine or brew 
  
Yakatizma: That can be fixed easily
			
		 | 
	
	
 Yakatizma follows through:
- 
https://web.archive.org/web/20011225...ders/sep00.htm
	Quote:
	
	
		
			
				9/29 新ベンダー各地に 
 
    と言ってもまだあまり確認できていないのですが。 
    Kaladim前(BBM)にHops,Maltのベンダー 
    HalasにOggok系のハーブベンダー 
    OggokにLargePlateMoldのベンダー 
    が既に見つかっています。 
    他にもいくつか追加されていると思います。 
 
From Google Translate: 
9/29 New vendors in various locations  
 
However, I haven't been able to confirm much yet. 
Vendor of Hops, Malt in front of Kaladim (BBM) 
Oggok Herbal Bender in Halas 
LargePlateMold Vendor on Oggok has already been found. 
I'm sure there are a few other additions.
			
		 | 
	
	
 Using EQTraders, we can compare Butcherblock captures before and after the patch (
May2000 vs 
Oct2000) to see the vendor in question is 
Inudul Dumirgun.
However, from the May2000 capture, we see Inudul Dumirgun existed prior to the Sep2000 patch offering a different inventory.
This 
map of Butcherblock suggests Inudul offered general goods prior to the patch. Gamin Griststone (misspelled Fristone) is also listed as offering general goods.
In the May2000 EQTraders capture above, we see these two NPCs, as well as two others in zone, offering some fishing supplies:
	Quote:
	
	
		
			
				 Fishing 
* fishing pole, bait - Indudul Dumirgun (2839, -648, 1st shop on left out from Kaladim), Gamin Grimstone (2721, -941, 3rd shop on left out from Kaladim), Felen Razdal (tower ruins, 128, 2386) , Parn Gylwyn (dock, 1458, 2823)
			
		 | 
	
	
 With the exception of Inudul, it appears the inventory of these merchants never changed:
- Gamin Griststone - 
https://eqtraders.com/sources/mob_it...php?MobID=1078
- Felen Razdal - 
https://eqtraders.com/sources/mob_it...php?MobID=1079
- Parn Gylwyn - 
https://eqtraders.com/sources/mob_it...php?MobID=1080
(These 3 NPCs could use a slight touch-up of their inventories. As I recall, each may have been missing an item or two from what's listed above.)
References to Inudul selling food and drink prior to the patch:
- 
https://groups.google.com/g/alt.game...m/1Pyf9UNz8CcJ
	Quote:
	
	
		
			
				Tom, Janene, & Nikki 
Mar 10, 1999, 8:00:00 AM 
 
Buy Milk outside of Kaladim in the first building to your left as you leave the 
city. Muffins aren't available and neither is bread, so you'll be stuck buying 
rations which cost several silver. 
 
Allara
			
		 | 
	
	
 - 
https://groups.google.com/g/alt.game...m/yUIB7Q2srwgJ
	Quote:
	
	
		
			
				Edward James Kilsdonk 
Feb 21, 2000, 8:00:00 AM 
 
In article <38b6b22b...@netnews.att.net>, 
 
Cranky <tkpr...@worldnet.att.net> wrote: 
>They said in first post they were in Kaladim which is a town I have 
>had a problem finding food/water in before myself .Don't think I ever 
>did locate any so I avoid ever visiting that town anymore : ) 
 
No one sells muffins in Kaladim or, as near as I could tell, 
anywhere in faydwer. 
 
In Kaladim the merchant standing outside the cleric guild in 
North Kaladim sells rations, milk and water. 
 
In Butcherblock the high elf standing by the boat docks and the 
high elf in the first hut to the left of the kaladim gate also 
sell food and drink. 
 
Ted K. 
Who has played far too many characters who start in Faydwer. 
...
			
		 | 
	
	
 
	Quote:
	
	
		
			
				VT Tym 
Feb 22, 2000, 8:00:00 AM 
 
The first house on your left outside the city, there's a high elf in 
there.. sells food and water. 
 
And I know somewhere inside they sell too, just can't remember offhand.. 
...
			
		 | 
	
	
 Aside from Inudul, the only other vendors in the first building to the left when exiting Kaladim are dwarves selling smithing molds.
Proposed Changes
- Remove the out of era brewing supplies from Hanamaf Darkfoam
- Revert Inudul Dumirgun's inventory to that of a general goods merchant until Sep2000
- Replace Inudul's inventory with current brewing supply inventory in Sep2000
- Add missing items to Gamin Griststone, Felen Razdal, and Parn Glywyn as needed