Looking into this quest it seems like the cats should attack you when handing keys in to the erudites, and the fact that you got no experience is somewhat classic but you should at least get an experience message (although not sure if you had indifferent or better faction):
http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/q...tml?quest=1241
Quote:
Mar 18 2001*
I spent awhile killing the Jailer, and saved up 16 keys. At level 13, turning in 16 keys provided no visible movement of my blue experience bar.*
|
Doesn't seem like it gives out any faction or money either.