I'd say Java or Silverlight would be your best bets if you want to go purely web-based. You could make a browser MUD environment in PHP/Python/Perl etc. with AJAX but it would be an even bigger pain in the ass.
Do note: a lot of modern MUDs do the backend servers in C++/Python/etc., then have a Flash telnet client for the browser.
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]