BONUS: a rotation (no matter how shitty it was, this was due to the sudden happening case that both guilds got hit at the time, something only seen once every 4 years) can be set up and with more talks an even better rotation could have been adjusted in a fair matter.
Sadly if it's not A / A brain trust, it can not happen. I've notice how most or all new raid rules is because Awakened or Aftermath thought of it, and created the rules (so it best benefits them when passed). It should be a joint task, and voted on not just something one guild says "sign on or fuck you" rules proposals. Each raiding group (CSA FAV, A , A, Kiitens who Divinity) should be allowed to propose new rules, change old ones, and have a vote take place. When/if more groups are in favor of proposals, it passes, and becomes law(unlike now when Awakened doesn't get their way, they throw a fit and force a change anyways). It can take time (like a 2 week discussion before a votes happen) but each raiding guild who can show the ability to raid certain targets / zones effectively should have the same amount of say about rule changes that directly affect them. I also believe guilds should work together to weed out people sticking their alts in to multiple guilds and compare certain aspects to ensure 1 player, 1 guild.
The days of 1 guild making rules to better suit their cause should be over (should have ended with TMO) and every guild who is able and willing to kill the targets in question should have say on tracking rules, FTE rules, and allowed tactics, etc for a healthy server going forward.
Such as if a guild is able to kill Kunark open zone dragons but not kill in VP, their vote wouldn't count towards changes in VP, only Kunark open zone dragons. Same goes for ToV Dragons, if a guild is able to kill every dragon besides a few key dragons, they should be allowed to vote for changes for all dragons besides key dragons. Each guild can openly post, and always discuss changes, and punishments for guilds unable, unwilling, or incapable of killing dragons. Doing this is the only way we as a community on this server can actually improve the server as whole.
|