#22
|
||||
|
Quote:
| |||
|
#23
|
||||
|
Quote:
__________________
Part of me says I can't keep drinking like this. The other part of me says, "Don't listen to that guy. He's drunk" | |||
|
#24
|
||||
|
@Sirken
Quote:
No one in my guild is arguing that TMO didnt have FTE and loot rights. We do however want to know all the unwritten rules that are considered for each encounter so we can know before we are arbitrarily rule against. No one in my guild should have been sending you tells concerning this except for the raid leaders present. So I'll handle that - let me know who they were for disciplinary actions. When you jump into guild chat and throw out random crap about first to damage in a clear cut case that TMO had FTE. You make us rethinkwhat the fuck is going on. Since you say that on his encounter it is different because getting agro doesnt matter but first to damage matters. This encounter had 3 pullers that ran back to the raid (crazyeyes, veloci, yamaksi) all 3 that could have damaged inny on the pull with a javelin or dagger or whatever. How do u tell from the log? Is that even the damage you are talking about? Maybe you mean the first damage done to the mob when it got to the raid's camp? What the fuck do you mean by first damage? You are the one who has confused the issue, now explain it. Encounter Details Encounter Details Server: Live Encounter ID: 109757515 Entity Count: 48 Spawned: Fri Jan 04, 2013; 13:50:00 Engaged: Fri Jan 04, 2013; 14:23:40 Death: Fri Jan 04, 2013; 14:25:37 Duration: 1 Minutes, 57 Seconds. (117 Seconds) Merited To: Group 2336 Kill Stolen: No # Entity Name Guild Name Level Class Engage Delay Disengage Length Group Damage Hate 1 Crazyeyes (140782)[1846] The Mystical Order 60 Rogue 14:23:40 0 14:25:37 117 2336 5124 1888 2 Veloci (224578)[1819] Forceful Entry 59 Monk 14:23:41 1 14:25:37 116 0 1796 1354 3 Yamakasi (272403)[1814] (O) Bregan D`Aerth 60 Monk 14:23:43 3 14:25:19 96 2341 2594 3168 4 Geleana (140690)[1848] The Mystical Order 60 Bard 14:24:13 33 14:25:37 84 2336 0 0 5 Sworen (69138)[1845] The Mystical Order 60 Warrior 14:24:24 44 14:24:31 7 2336 10 657 6 Knix (254923)[1847] The Mystical Order 60 Druid 14:24:25 45 14:24:35 10 2336 0 113 7 Anthrax (41686)[1825] (O) Bregan D`Aerth 60 Warrior 14:24:25 45 14:25:37 72 2341 986 1982 8 Cephalic (217872)[1822] Bregan D`Aerth 60 Rogue 14:24:35 55 14:25:37 62 2349 2033 967 9 Bolloney (242013)[1844] The Mystical Order 55 Ranger 14:24:35 55 14:25:37 62 2336 1428 1341 10 Vitus (331462)[1823] Divinity 60 Monk 14:24:35 55 14:24:47 12 0 531 669 11 Suirad (133701)[1826] Bregan D`Aerth 60 Ranger 14:24:38 58 14:25:37 59 2349 944 1163 12 Imba (341369)[1828] (O) Forceful Entry 60 Warrior 14:24:39 59 14:25:12 33 0 714 3977 13 Verenity (178596)[1815] (O) Bregan D`Aerth 60 Cleric 14:24:40 60 14:25:37 57 2341 0 169 14 Xerxes (267241)[1852] Bregan D`Aerth 60 Monk 14:24:41 61 14:25:00 19 2349 656 895 15 Mithor (250149)[1858] The Mystical Order 60 Necromancer 14:24:41 61 14:25:15 34 2344 0 0 16 Necrious (23585)[1855] The Mystical Order 59 Necromancer 14:24:42 62 14:24:47 5 2344 0 828 17 Xaine (200189)[1830] Bregan D`Aerth 60 Warrior 14:24:42 62 14:25:37 55 0 1021 1834 18 Kindadar (240819)[1854] The Mystical Order 60 Druid 14:24:43 63 14:25:37 54 2344 0 1210 19 Kaerik (229687)[1860] The Mystical Order 60 Cleric 14:24:45 65 14:25:37 52 2336 0 119 20 Doraf (9561)[1813] Forceful Entry 60 Cleric 14:24:47 67 14:25:37 50 0 0 43 21 Versager (257638)[1820] Forceful Entry 60 Wizard 14:24:47 67 14:24:51 4 0 0 875 22 Mithra (306864)[1850] Forceful Entry 54 Rogue 14:24:52 72 14:25:37 45 2352 1932 1996 23 Jambi (32864)[1839] Forceful Entry 56 Shadow Knight 14:24:57 77 14:25:34 37 2352 673 2725 24 Sookie (273505)[1818] Forceful Entry 46 Druid 14:24:59 79 14:25:37 38 0 0 16 25 Sckrilla (68129)[1876] The Mystical Order 60 Rogue 14:24:59 79 14:25:37 38 2359 2830 73 26 Jeremy (10654)[1867] (O) The Mystical Order 60 Shaman 14:25:00 80 14:25:37 37 2351 1350 2469 27 Taelara (300167)[1874] The Mystical Order 59 Druid 14:25:01 81 14:25:37 36 0 0 1431 28 Tinyscare (158296)[1864] The Mystical Order 60 Necromancer 14:25:02 82 14:25:37 35 2337 0 161 29 Mithor's Pet (a_kiraikuei) (76009)[1680] The Mystical Order 50 Monk 14:25:02 82 14:25:11 9 2344 243 277 30 Xerxes (267241)[1852] Bregan D`Aerth 60 Monk 14:25:03 83 14:25:37 34 2349 2823 1673 31 Kegluas (69548)[1877] The Mystical Order 60 Warrior 14:25:03 83 14:25:31 28 2359 932 2180 32 Puyi (348534)[1832] Forceful Entry 58 Cleric 14:25:03 83 14:25:37 34 0 6 106 33 Qanelar (233836)[1824] Bregan D`Aerth 51 Cleric 14:25:04 84 14:25:37 33 2360 0 0 34 Vitus (331462)[1823] Divinity 60 Monk 14:25:04 84 14:25:37 33 0 985 1278 35 Worship (311313)[1838] Forceful Entry 52 Monk 14:25:10 90 14:25:37 27 2338 302 890 36 Krythis (340384)[1837] Forceful Entry 56 Bard 14:25:10 90 14:25:37 27 2338 0 0 37 Falling's Pet (an_ire_ghast) (76008)[1557] The Mystical Order 50 Shadow Knight 14:25:11 91 14:25:37 26 2351 345 985 38 Falling (107590)[1871] The Mystical Order 59 Necromancer 14:25:11 91 14:25:37 26 2351 0 0 39 Aenarie (108089)[1868] The Mystical Order 57 Cleric 14:25:12 92 14:25:37 25 2351 0 57 40 Lorea's Pet (SumMageMultiElement) (598)[1884] The Mystical Order 49 Warrior 14:25:12 92 14:25:37 25 2351 750 994 41 Lorea (51498)[1870] The Mystical Order 60 Magician 14:25:12 92 14:25:37 25 2351 0 0 42 Yamakasi (272403)[1814] (O) Bregan D`Aerth 60 Monk 14:25:20 100 14:25:37 17 2341 3467 1811 43 Gabtik (198143)[1834] Forceful Entry 60 Wizard 14:25:21 101 14:25:37 16 2338 2475 2625 44 Tobli (299462)[1863] The Mystical Order 59 Cleric 14:25:23 103 14:25:37 14 2337 0 28 45 Mithor (250149)[1858] The Mystical Order 60 Necromancer 14:25:28 108 14:25:37 9 2344 0 0 46 Breachin (125637)[1880] The Mystical Order 51 Wizard 14:25:32 112 14:25:37 5 0 0 679 47 Dexs (93254)[1836] (O) Inglourious Basterds 60 Druid 14:25:35 115 14:25:37 2 0 386 1194 48 Hiphopotamus (287747)[1816] Forceful Entry 59 Druid 14:25:36 116 14:25:37 1 2352 0 16 | |||
|
#25
|
|||
|
The only thing he could possibly be saying with reguards to "first to damage" is :
if a guild is pulling a raid boss, Sirken says it is ok to run out ahead of that raid force and do dmg to the mob before it gets into their camp. Then you can petition for FTD? Is that how you are lining out the new rule? | ||
|
#26
|
|||
|
So if I throw a ranged item at Inny and it misses and he aggro's me... then random puller from another guild throws a ranged item which lands on Inny doing 1 damage then they have the rights to the kill?
| ||
|
#27
|
|||
|
what did he drop?
| ||
|
#28
|
||||
|
Quote:
brilliant. Is this is like the episode where Kirk tells fembot #248 he likes her, and fembot # 921 he does not like her, even though they are identical, and then they both start smoking out from their heads?
__________________
go go go
| |||
|
#29
|
|||
|
lol we been going through this for months and months on end, but nothing changes...so just figure out new ways to get FTE. Apparently TMO is allowed to train in PoHate when they know they will lose a mob, or kite dragons around zones for 5-10 minutes while there is a raid force in zone until TMO has more then 8 people in zone to kill it(fraps of sev being kited around city of mist apparently don't prove anything). I wouldn't suggest trying those things if you aren't in TMO, but yeah.
I give up with the entire FTE argument, we all know its a broken and bullshit rule made up to benefit TMO, and when it stops benefitting them it will be changed. Hence why I came up with my idea for a server-wide all out poopsock alliance against TMO until something changes. | ||
|
#30
|
||||
|
Quote:
| |||
|
|
|