Project 1999

Go Back   Project 1999 > Server Issues > Resolved Issues

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 06-25-2010, 02:37 AM
mmiles8 mmiles8 is offline
Fire Giant

mmiles8's Avatar

Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 642
Default Broken Tradeskill Combines

Requesting this be stickied, as mentioned in another thread. I'd like to turn it into a single thread for tradeskill combines that aren't working. It would cut down on forum clutter and give us a place to consolidate some efforts.

Quote:
Fixed recipes, kept for reference.

Hulgarsh
Vodka x 2
Cask
Fishing Bait
Water Flask
Yield 3, Trivial 155 (Returns cask on failure)

Ginesh
Short Beer
Shotglass
Vegetables
Water Flash
Yield 2, Trivial 168 (Returns shotglass on failure)

Dwarf Chops
Dwarf Meat
Spices
Garnish
Yield 2, Trivial 36


Beer Braised Wolf
Wolf Meat
Spices
Short Beer
Yield 2, Trivial 68

Beer Braised Rat
Rat Meat
Spices
Short Beer
Yield 2, Trivial 68

Skewers:Pottery(Unfired Skewers)
Block of Clay
Skewers Sketch
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 21

Skewers:Smithing
Metal Bits
Skewer Mold
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 38

Medium Jar(Unfired Medium Container)
Block of Clay
Medium Jar Sketch
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 36

Cake Round:Pottery(Unfired Cake Round)
Block of Clay
Cake Round Sketch
Glass Shard
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 115

Cake Round:Smithing
Metal Bits
Cake Round Mold
Ceramic Lining
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 38

Muffin Tin:Smithing
Metal Bits
Ceramic Lining
Muffin Tin Mold
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 35

Muffin Tin:Pottery(Unfired Muffin Tin)
Metal Bits
Block of Clay
Muffin Tin Sketch
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 122

Pot:Pottery(Unfired Pot)
Large Block of Clay
Metal Bits
Pot Sketch
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 56

Smoker:Smithing
Metal Bits
Skewers
Smoker Base Mold
Smoker Support Mold
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 50

Smoker:Pottery(Unfired Smoker)
Large Block of Clay
Smoker Sketch
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 82

Troll Shaped Cookie Cutter:Smithing
Metal Bits
Troll Cookie Mold
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 40

Troll Shaped Cookie Cutter:Pottery(Unfired Troll Cookie Cutter)
Small Block of Clay
Troll Template
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 102

Barbarian Shaped Cookie Cutter:Smithing
Metal Bits
Barbarian Cookie Mold
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 40

Barbarian Shaped Cookie Cutter:Pottery(Unfired Barbarian Cookie Cutter)
Small Block of Clay
Barbarian Template
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 102

Gnome Shaped Cookie Cutter:Smithing
Metal Bits
Gnome Cookie Mold
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 40

Gnome Shaped Cookie Cutter:Pottery(Unfired Gnome Cookie Cutter)
Small Block of Clay
Gnome Template
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 102

Animal Shaped Cookie Cutter:Smithing
Metal Bits
Animal Cookie Mold
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 40

Animal Shaped Cookie Cutter:Pottery(Unfired Animal Cookie Cutter)
Small Block of Clay
Animal Template
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 102

Crushed Flame Agate:Baking - In Mixing Bowl
Flame Agate x 2
Yield 1, Trivial 15 (No-fail)

Crushed Flame Agate:Make Poison - In Mortar and Pestle <- Functions, but is possible to fail.
Flame Agate x 2
Yield 1, Trivial 15 (No-fail)

Small Buckler
Small Buckler Mold
Sheet Metal
Water Flask
Smithy Hammer
Yield 1, Trivial 62 (Returns Smithy Hammer on Failure AND Success)

Buckler
Buckler Mold
Sheet Metal
Water Flask
Smithy Hammer
Yield 1, Trivial 62 (Returns Smithy Hammer on Failure AND Success)

Large Buckler
Large Buckler Mold
Sheet Metal
Water Flask
Smithy Hammer
Yield 1, Trivial 62 (Returns Smithy Hammer on Failure AND Success)

Small Kite Shield
Small Kite Shield Mold
2 Medium Quality Sheet Metal
Water Flask
Smithy Hammer
Yield 1, Trivial 82 (Returns Smithy Hammer on Failure AND Success)

Kite Shield
Kite Shield Mold
2 Medium Quality Sheet Metal
Water Flask
Smithy Hammer
Yield 1, Trivial 82 (Returns Smithy Hammer on Failure AND Success)

Large Kite Shield
Large Kite Shield Mold
2 Medium Quality Sheet Metal
Water Flask
Smithy Hammer
Yield 1, Trivial 82 (Returns Smithy Hammer on Failure AND Success)

Gnome Kabobs
Gnome Meat
Spices
Jug of Sauces
Skewers
Yield 2, Trivial 56 (Returns Skewers on Failure AND Success)

Smoked Wood Elf: (Potentially bugged, unable to test)
Wood Elf Parts
Spices
Smoker
Yield 2, Trivial 95 (Returns Smoker on Failure AND Success)

Birthday Cake
Clump of Dough
Frosting
Winter Chocolate
Cake Round
Yield 2, Trivial 162 (Returns Cake Round on Failure AND Success)


Birthday Cake Slice: (Potentially bugged, unable to test)
Birthday Cake
Yield 10, Trivial 15 (No-Fail)

Wedding Cake
Clump of Dough
Frosting
White Chocolate
Cake Round
Yield 2, Trivial 162 (Returns Cake Round on Failure AND Success)


Wedding Cake Slice: (Potentially bugged, unable to test)
Wedding Cake
Yield 10, Trivial 15 (No-Fail)

All subcombines combine in a Concordance of Research:

Practice Rune (Azia)
Lapis Lazuli
Bat Wing
Bone Chips
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail)

Practice Rune (Beza)
Turquoise
Fire Beetle Eye
Any Rusty Slashing Weapon
  • Rusty Two Handed Sword
  • Rusty Two Handed Battle Axe
  • Rusty Bastard Sword
  • Rusty Broad Sword
  • Rusty Short Sword
  • Rusty Long Sword
  • Rusty Halberd
  • Rusty Scythe
  • Rusty Scimitar
  • Rusty Battle Axe
  • Rusty Fer`Esh
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail)

Apprentice Rune (Azia)
Hematite
Bixie Wing
Froglok Eye
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Apprentice Rune (Beza)
Cat's Eye Agate
Large Snake Rattle
Any Rusty Weapon
  • Rusty Mace
  • Rusty Flail
  • Rusty Morning Star
  • Rusty Warhammer
  • Rusty Dagger
  • Rusty Rapier
  • Rusty Spear
  • Rusty Shortened Spear
  • Rusty Two Handed Hammer
  • Rusty Two Handed Sword
  • Rusty Two Handed Battle Axe
  • Rusty Bastard Sword
  • Rusty Broad Sword
  • Rusty Short Sword
  • Rusty Long Sword
  • Rusty Halberd
  • Rusty Scythe
  • Rusty Scimitar
  • Rusty Battle Axe
  • Rusty Fer`Esh
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Training Rune (Azia)
Bloodstone
Wasp Wing
Zombie Skin
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Training Rune (Beza)
Onyx
Spiderling Silk
Raw-hide armor (Any size raw-hide Skullcap, Mask, Gorget, Tunic, Shoulderpads, or Cloak)
  • Small Raw-hide Skullcap
  • Raw-hide Skullcap
  • Large Raw-hide Skullcap
  • Small Raw-hide Mask
  • Raw-hide Mask
  • Large Raw-hide Mask
  • Small Raw-hide Gorget
  • Raw-hide Gorget
  • Large Raw-hide Gorget
  • Small Raw-hide Tunic
  • Raw-hide Tunic
  • Large Raw-hide Tunic
  • Small Raw-hide Shoulderpads
  • Raw-hide Shoulderpads
  • Large Raw-hide Shoulderpads
  • Small Raw-hide Cloak
  • Raw-hide Cloak
  • Large Raw-hide Cloak
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Journeyman Rune (Azia)
Jasper
Pixie Wing
Bat Fur
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Journeyman Rune (Beza)
Star Rose Quartz
Burned Out Lightstone
Raw-hide armor (Any Size - Belt, Sleeves, Wristbands, Gloves, Leggings, or Boots)
  • Small Raw-hide Belt
  • Raw-hide Belt
  • Large Raw-hide Belt
  • Small Raw-hide Sleeves
  • Raw-hide Sleeves
  • Large Raw-hide Sleeves
  • Small Raw-hide Wristbands
  • Raw-hide Wristbands
  • Large Raw-hide Wristbands
  • Small Raw-hide Gloves
  • Raw-hide Gloves
  • Large Raw-hide Gloves
  • Small Raw-hide Leggings
  • Raw-hide Leggings
  • Large Raw-hide Leggings
  • Small Raw-hide Boots
  • Raw-hide Boots
  • Large Raw-hide Boots
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Study Rune (Azia)
Amber
Giant Bat Wing
Giant Scarab Eye
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Study Rune (Beza)
Amber
Giant Snake Fang
Ringmail (Any Size Coif, Visor, neckguard, Coat, Mantle, or Cape)
  • Small Ringmail Coif
  • Ringmail Coif
  • Large Ringmail Coif
  • Small Ringmail Visor
  • Ringmail Visor
  • Large Ringmail Visor
  • Small Ringmail Neckguard
  • Ringmail Neckguard
  • Large Ringmail Neckguard
  • Small Ringmail Coat
  • Ringmail Coat
  • Large Ringmail Coat
  • Small Ringmail Mantle
  • Ringmail Mantle
  • Large Ringmail Mantle
  • Small Ringmail Cape
  • Ringmail Cape
  • Large Ringmail Cape
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Expert Rune (Azia)
Jade
Faerie Wing
Fire Drake Scales
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Expert Rune (Beza)
Jade
Giant Snake Rattle
Ringmail (Any Size Skirt, Belt, Sleeves, Bracelet, Gloves, Pants, or Boots)
  • Small Ringmail Skirt
  • Ringmail Skirt
  • Large Ringmail Skirt
  • Small Ringmail Belt
  • Ringmail Belt
  • Large Ringmail Belt
  • Small Ringmail Sleeves
  • Ringmail Sleeves
  • Large Ringmail Sleeves
  • Small Ringmail Bracelet
  • Ringmail Bracelet
  • Large Ringmail Bracelet
  • Small Ringmail Gloves
  • Ringmail Gloves
  • Large Ringmail Gloves
  • Small Ringmail Pants
  • Ringmail Pants
  • Large Ringmail Pants
  • Small Ringmail Boots
  • Ringmail Boots
  • Large Ringmail Boots
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Master Rune (Azia)
Pearl
Griffon Feather
Undead Froglok Tongue
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Master Rune (Beza)
Pearl
Giant Fire Beetle Eye
Any Fine Steel Slashing Weapon
  • Fine Steel Two Handed Sword
  • Fine Steel Short Sword
  • Fine Steel Long Sword
  • Fine Steel Scimitar
  • Fine Steel Ulak
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Magi Rune (Azia)
Topaz
Shark Skin
Brownie Parts
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)

Magi Rune (Beza)
Topaz
Giant Toes
  • Hill Giant Toes
  • Ice Giant Toes
  • Fire Giant Toes
Any Fine Steel Piercing or Blunt Weapon
  • Fine Steel Great Staff
  • Fine Steel Morning Star
  • Fine Steel Warhammer
  • Fine Steel Dagger
  • Fine Steel Rapier
  • Fine Steel Spear
Piece of Parchment
Quill
Yield 1, Trivial 0 (No-Fail) (Returns Quill on Failure AND Success)


All recipes listed below combine in each class's research container:

Enchanter: Tome of Endless Enchantments
Mage: Elemental Grimoire
Wizard: Lexicon
Necromancer: Book of Dark Bindings

Practice Rune (Complete)
Practice Rune (Azia)
Practice Rune (Beza)
Yield 1, Trivial 21

Apprentice Rune (Complete)
Apprentice Rune (Azia)
Apprentice Rune (Beza)
Yield 1, Trivial 41

Training Rune (Complete)
Training Rune (Azia)
Training Rune (Beza)
Yield 1, Trivial 62

Journeyman Rune (Complete)
Journeyman Rune (Azia)
Journeyman Rune (Beza)
Yield 1, Trivial 95

Study Rune (Complete)
Study Rune (Azia)
Study Rune (Beza)
Yield 1, Trivial 122

Expert Rune (Complete)
Expert Rune (Azia)
Expert Rune (Beza)
Yield 1, Trivial 142

Master Rune (Complete)
Master Rune (Azia)
Master Rune (Beza)
Yield 1, Trivial 162

Magi Rune (Complete)
Magi Rune (Azia)
Magi Rune (Beza)
Yield 1, Trivial 182
Last edited by Uthgaard; 09-23-2010 at 07:27 AM..
  #2  
Old 06-25-2010, 02:32 PM
Alex Alex is offline
Banned


Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 245
Default

I would also like to see all broken tradeskill recipes etc merged into one thread, this is a good idea. Would benefit alot of people.

Could we get a sticky on this?
  #3  
Old 06-25-2010, 02:41 PM
astarothel astarothel is offline
Fire Giant

astarothel's Avatar

Join Date: Apr 2010
Posts: 608
Default

Something very similar to this will be happening shortly, don't worry.

ps.: Snake Pickles aren't classic. This is the sort of thing you have to look out for.
__________________
More famous than Jesus and better dressed than Santa Claus;
wouldn't be seen dead on a cross and have never been caught up a chimney.
So I deserve your money more
Last edited by astarothel; 06-25-2010 at 02:45 PM..
  #4  
Old 06-25-2010, 03:14 PM
guineapig guineapig is offline
Planar Protector

guineapig's Avatar

Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 4,028
Default

Bump!

And thank you for all the work and research done Astarothel!

I think it's safe to say that all the above recipes have been proven to be in the game back in 1999 and hopefully we will see them implemented within the next patch or 2.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by nilbog View Post
Server chat is for civil conversation. Personal attacks/generally being confrontational will not be tolerated.
  #5  
Old 06-25-2010, 03:28 PM
mmiles8 mmiles8 is offline
Fire Giant

mmiles8's Avatar

Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 642
Default

Refer to Guineapig's Post here re: snake pickles
http://www.project1999.org/forums/sh...ad.php?t=10239

And yes, I only included recipes here that were proven to be in game.

A LOT of recipes were in game in classic. One thing to keep in mind is that throughout most of classic, eqtraders was explicitly not a recipe source, it was designed as more of a bazaar, and a collaborative place for traders to work. Niami didn't begin listing recipes on a large scale until closer to Kunark.

The entire tradeskill community across all servers only numbered in the hundreds until the velious tradeskill boom as a result of the prayer shawl, so many classically proven recipes (the names are listed in the recipe books on the vendors) weren't actually discovered until kunark or later (Chocolate Covered Cherries and Pixie Powder Cinnesticks for example weren't discovered until velious).
  #6  
Old 06-25-2010, 03:52 PM
astarothel astarothel is offline
Fire Giant

astarothel's Avatar

Join Date: Apr 2010
Posts: 608
Default

I have 2 very complete lists from Kunark that don't list snake pickles which is why I am a little reluctant about them. The Item ID 20397 for snake pickles is also a little strange, being pretty well sandwiched by Kunark era IDs and recipes, and while I don't rely on ItemIDs blindly it is peculiar. While it may be listed in one of the classic era cookbooks, it doesn't necessarily mean it was implemented in classic.

Chocolate Marr Cherries and Pixie Powder Cinnesticks were presumably both added to the game at the same time (IDs are consecutive), and came very late in classic, maybe even bridging into Kunark, so it wouldn't really surprise me if they were found out later on.
__________________
More famous than Jesus and better dressed than Santa Claus;
wouldn't be seen dead on a cross and have never been caught up a chimney.
So I deserve your money more
Last edited by astarothel; 06-25-2010 at 03:56 PM..
  #7  
Old 06-25-2010, 03:59 PM
Fahn Fahn is offline
Aviak


Join Date: May 2010
Location: Tae-has
Posts: 59
Default

Not sure if it was classic, but seems to be.

Bug Bites
http://www.eqtraders.com/items/show_item.php?item=3877&menustr=080020020000


Anyway, the combine does not work.
  #8  
Old 06-25-2010, 04:00 PM
mmiles8 mmiles8 is offline
Fire Giant

mmiles8's Avatar

Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 642
Default

Judging by the content of Guineapig's post, I'd say the recipe was broken, and fixed, if ItemID is a consideration. Dont know if to fix something they had to completely remove it and re add it, or if ItemIDs are generated by the SQLserver, if it came in a patch with several other things being fixed, another item may have been assigned its old ID if it hit the database first.

Adding Bug Bites to the above list. Listed in: Sorin's Treats on the Go.
Also found Pickled Snake in Mixxy's Delicacies Vol 1. You can read it here: http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?item=20025

These books were in the game from day 1.
Last edited by mmiles8; 06-25-2010 at 04:20 PM..
  #9  
Old 06-27-2010, 02:17 AM
mmiles8 mmiles8 is offline
Fire Giant

mmiles8's Avatar

Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 642
Default

Back to the top!
  #10  
Old 06-27-2010, 10:54 AM
Flicka Flicka is offline
Kobold

Flicka's Avatar

Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 160
Default

Pot:Smithing
Metal Bits
Pot Mold
Standing Legs Mold
Water Flask
Yield 1, Trivial 50

This IS working, I made one last night (veggie soup anyone!?)

The pottery and smithing version of the CAKE ROUND is broken.
__________________
Nightmares, Fantasies, Hate, Love and Lust - why can't we have it all?
Closed Thread


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:01 PM.


Everquest is a registered trademark of Daybreak Game Company LLC.
Project 1999 is not associated or affiliated in any way with Daybreak Game Company LLC.
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.