Raid content appropriate for population?

[minakto]

Just wondering. I saw lazortag said dragon push works but you need 30-35 people. Thats great for blue. Considering usually i would assume you dont have 100% of your guild at your raid. 30-35 people for a raid probably translates to 40-45 people in the entire guild? Active pops seems to hover around 160. So 1/4 of a population is needed for raid mob to be done legit.

Looking at all the posts it seems every raid mob hasnt been killed with 100% legitimacy. I think 4-5 dragons raids loots have been taken away alreadt. And there is still speculation that guilds are still fighting dragons in a broken way, maybe not intentional but still the way these small guilds(compared to p99) are needed to do raid mobs is making them hover close to a position that might step over as an exploit. Refering to the Nihilum recent vox raid where if you stand in a certain spot where nihilum likes to pull do that it can be considered an exploit. It would be nice if the encounter was designed that a guild on a server with the population we have wouldnt have to tread so closely to that exploit spot.

[Foreverman]

Raid content is fine and is working, if you feel that you need 30 to 35 people to take out vox or naggy..there is a guild who shares the sames thoughts as you....

[Jigga]

Originally Posted by Foreverman [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Raid content is fine and is working, if you feel that you need 30 to 35 people to take out vox or naggy..there is a guild who shares the sames thoughts as you....

http://www.project1999.org/forums/sh...ad.php?t=61711

[Tassador]

Fifa 2012 ps3 lets do this pm me playa

[Lazortag]

For push to work on a mob as big a Vox you need a ton of people, but that doesn't mean the encounter is impossible without that many. And keep in mind this is the only boss in classic that cheals (unless there are some chealing Sky mobs that I don't know about). A boss like Naggy is trivially easy with Bard resists so long as you have a decent number of melees. I remember going through entire Naggy fights on p99 at level 50 where I'd never get feared/ae'd once. You don't need 35 people for Naggy, 20 is probably more appropriate. Vox is a different story, but still, raid mobs do not need to be made easier.

[Humerox]

Originally Posted by Lazortag [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

...raid mobs do not need to be made easier.

they need to be made harder, imo.

[fiegi]

Root em in a spot in the room where healers can't hide behind a wall

profit

[SamwiseRed]

log on blue, make a halfling, witness the body count

[nerfed]

Tank and Clerics alone would eventually kill naggy.

[Sgt1stClassPerkerwood]

agree