The only mistake they made was giving this chanter mixed messages (and Pallie's attitude as well). He left the zone, whereas they were there and the sword dropped. Quite frankly, whether or not they told him he can have 1 more attempt doesn't matter, he zoned twice and he wasn't there when they were at the camp. The rules were always on the group's side, despite what anyone else in this thread thinks. Because it doesn't matter, it holds no water. They were there, he wasn't. They got the kill, and according to the rules it should be theirs.
But somehow he has the sword, and somehow they're the bad guys. The big mistake was them sending him a tell in the first place. If things went differently, say they killed him and said absolutely nothing to the chanter but "you leave you lose" this wouldn't have been an incident at all. He'd have been here on the forums ranting about how he zoned and lost a camp and we'd all be laughing at him.
|