Im personnally in favor of a split rotation/"competition" system.
Half the pops rotated. No alt guilds or switching guilds as needed. You have to do the tracking on your own and kill the target in the hour after it pops. I'd like some kind of "progression" system too, like, you can't be on a rotation for VS or Trak if you can't kill Gorenaire on your own, or can't be on rotation for the kunark dragons if you can't kill Innoruuk.. stuff like that.
There's still a way for TMO to wave their dicks at everyone showing us all the phat loots they got on a 12 year old game..
Also, come on. Stop calling whatever is happening right now on this server is classic. I come from Karana server, with a gentleman agreement to rotate stuff.
LOL, competition:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VYQdmLgc71Q