Was Phallax in the right technically as far as rules go? I guess that depends on your interpertation of the rules. I would say that *technically* he was not actively in the camp so *technically* it was open.
Personally would I have handled the situation that way? No. I like Phallax. I've never had problems with him, he shows up to raids, and is quick to throw me STA and Tuna when I ask. Sure he can be mouthy on the boards, but I'm guilty of the same crime; so I can't fault the guy for that. That being said, I don't agree with the way he handled this situation. I'll be the first to admit that had I been in your place and he had tried to take the Ishva camp from me, we'd have had a serious problem.
My empathy for your situation ends there though. You're need to hop on the anti-DA band wagon by dragging a guild into a personal matter was uncalled for. If you wanted to inform the leadership of DA that Phallax was acting like a jack-off, there are far better ways to do that than ranting our guild.
|