No, they aren't wrong. My information is the product of weeks worth of comprehensive research and comparisons - a full table of checks with 6 different characters at varying faction levels - and much more accurate than nuking an npc and drawing an incorrect conclusion.
Code:
ally: 1051 to 2000
warmly: 701 to 1050
kindly: 451 to 700
amiable: 51 to 450
indifferent: -49 to 50
apprehensive: -449 to -50
dubious: -699 to -450
threatening: -1049 to -700
scowls: -2000 to -1050
OT
Human Shadowknight Innoruuk: Apprehensive
Gnome Shadowknight Innoruuk: Apprehensive
Dark-Elf Shadowknight Innoruuk: Apprehensive
Erudite Shadowknight Innoruuk: Apprehensive
Troll Shadowknight Innoruuk: Apprehensive
Troll Shadowknight Innoruuk: Apprehensive
Half-Elf Shadowknight Innoruuk: Scowls
High-Elf Shadowknight Innoruuk: Scowls
Wood-Elf Shadowknight Innoruuk: Scowls
Halfling Shadowknight Innoruuk: Scowls
Dwarf Shadowknight Innoruuk: Scowls
Barbarian Shadowknight Innoruuk: Scowls
Iksar Shadowknight Innoruuk: Scowls
10 hits to indifferent
15 hits and still indifferent
iksar = -700-250
-950
-100
----------------------------
SwiftTails: Done
CabilisResidents: Done
BroodofKotiz: Done
LegionofCabilis: Done
ScaledMystics: Done
CrusadersofGreenmist: Done
Monk Cazic Thule
+25 CrusadersofGreenmist
+50 SwiftTails
0 LegionofCabilis
0 CabilisResidents
+50 ScaledMystics
+50 BroodofKotiz
Monk Agnostic
+50 SwiftTails
0 LegionofCabilis
0 CabilisResidents
+50 ScaledMystics
+50 BroodofKotiz
+25 CrusadersofGreenmist
Rogue Agnostic
Indifferent to all
Bard Agnostic
Scowls to ScaledMystics
Indifferent to all else
Agnostic Enchanter
Scowls to ScaledMystics
Indifferent to all else
Agnostic Wizard
Scowls to ScaledMystics
Indifferent to all else
Bertoxxolous
Dubious with CrusadersofGreenmist
Indifferent to all else
Innoruuk
Dubious with CrusadersofGreenmist
Indifferent to all else
Warrior Agnostic
Amiable with LegionofCabilis
Indifferent to all else
Veeshan
Every faction Scowls -1500
Bristlebane
Every faction Scowls -1500
Rallos
Every faction Scowls -1500
Cleric Cazic
Amiable to ScaledMystics and BroodofKotiz
Indifferent to all else
Solusek Ro
Everything Scowls
Racial mods:
All factions
Iksar = 0
All other = -1500
ScaledMystics Scowls to brd enc mage wiz
Shm Note
+100 ScaledMystics
+25 LegionofCabilis
Shm before note
0 hits: amiable to ScaledMystics
0 hits: indifferent to LegionofCabilis
0 hits: indifferent to CrusadersofGreenmist
0 hits: indifferent to Swifttails
25 hits: amiable to CrusadersofGreenmist
50 hits: amiable to LegionofCabilis
50 hits: amiable to Swifttails
350 hits: kindly to ScaledMystics
* Handing in Note *
425 hits: kindly to LegionofCabilis
500 hits: warmly to ScaledMystics
War note
+100 LegionofCabilis
+25 CabilisResident
+25 SwiftTails
+25 CrusadersofGreenmist
+25 ScaledMystics
War before note
0 hits: amiable to ScaledMystics
0 hits: amiable to LegionofCabilis
0 hits: indifferent to CabilisResidents
0 hits: indifferent to CrusadersofGreenmist
0 hits: indifferent to Swifttails
25 hits: amiable to CrusadersofGreenmist
50 hits: amiable to CabilisResidents
50 hits: amiable to Swifttails
400 hits: kindly to LegionofCabilis
400 hits: kindly to ScaledMystics
425 hits: kindly to CrusadersofGreenmist
* Handing in Note *
550 hits: warmly to LegionofCabilis
625 hits: warmly to ScaledMystics
650 hits: warmly to CrusadersofGreenmist
SK note
+100 CrusadersofGreenmist
+25 LegionofCabilis
Shd before note
0 hits: amiable to ScaledMystics
0 hits: indifferent to LegionofCabilis
0 hits: indifferent to CabilisResidents
0 hits: amiable to CrusadersofGreenmist
0 hits: indifferent to Swifttails
50 hits: amiable to LegionofCabilis
50 hits: amiable to CabilisResidents
50 hits: amiable to Swifttails
400 hits: kindly to CrusadersofGreenmist
400 hits: kindly to ScaledMystics
* Handing in Note *
425 hits: Kindly to Legion
550 hits: warmly to CrusadersofGreenmist
Monk note
+200 SwiftTails
+50 LegionofCabilis
Monk before note
0 hits: Amiable to Swifttails
400 hits: kindly to SwiftTails
650 hits: warmly to SwiftTails
1000 hits: ally to SwiftTails
0 hits: indifferent to LegionofCabilis
50 hits: amiable to LegionofCabilis
450 hits: kindly to LegionofCabilis
700 hits: warmly to LegionofCabilis
1050 hits: ally to LegionofCabilis
Monk after note: +LegionofCabilis; +SwiftTails
400 hits: kindly to LegionofCabilis
650 hits: warmly to LegionofCabilis
1000 hits: ally to LegionofCabilis
1950 hits: maxed with LegionofCabilis
Warmly to SwiftTails between 401 and 450
~800 hits: Ally to SwiftTails
1800 hits: maxed with Swifttails
25 hits: amiable to CrusadersofGreenmist
425 hits: kindly to CrusadersofGreenmist
675 hits: warmly to CrusadersofGreenmist
1025 hits: ally to CrusadersofGreenmist
2000 hits: maxed with CrusadersofGreenmist
400 hits: kindly to ScaledMystics
650 hits: warmly to ScaledMystics
1000 hits: ally to ScaledMystics
2000 hits: maxed with ScaledMystics
50 hits: amiable to CabilisResidents
450 hits: kindly to CabilisResidents
700 hits: warmly to CabilisResidents
1050 hits: ally to CabilisResidents
2000 hits: maxed with CabilisResidents
50 hits: amiable to CabilisResidents
450 hits: kindly to CabilisResidents
700 hits: warmly to CabilisResidents
1050 hits: ally to CabilisResidents
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
This is how you research a faction. Not by nuking one mob and drawing an incorrect conclusion to justify an incorrect decision. But by all means, make yet another incorrect edit to the factions. Your changes are the main reason why my eight month old db is more accurate than what's currently on the server. If one desires to gloat over correcting another, it's typically beneficial to be correct.