This is a terrible question to ask the community of a Classic server. It's going to become a Classic/Kunark/Velious circle jerk and "everything Space Cats and beyond is the devil's heathen work and no one can have differing opinions from mine!"
To put in my input however, though I've said it before, Luclin was peak for me content wise. Client wise, Live as it is today.
What I mean by that is, generally speaking, the zones and mob layouts, quests, items, and over all feeling was superior between Classic and Luclin. PoP+ took a toll on that for me, and once GoD dropped, in my mind, it never truly recovered. However when it comes to the way the client itself handles. The functionalities they put in and tweaked (Pet window, Raid Window/raid system, Guild manager etc), and the design of the UI, how it handles with your computer etc etc etc. It is far superior now (now meaning if you were to log on Live today..Veil of Alaris) than it ever was.
With the EQEmu team working on chasing the Live client atm I'm going to go ahead and say a P99-like server (Velious or Luclin max expac) with Veil of Alaris client compatibility would be the best thing in the world to me.
|