[Tallenn]

But you're not providing any evidence that it's any different than it was back then. I remember it as being absolutely horrible for a low level melee to kill anything- hence, why I never leveled any of them very far.

You are claiming to remember it differently. However, you aren't providing any proof. It's 11 years- everyone's memories are going to be somewhat different. In my memory (and it seems in the memory of several other posters), low level melee is pretty much the same as it was in classic. In your memory (and admittedly, in the memory of others, as well), it's not.

How do you propose to solve this discrepancy? Do you perchance, have any screenshots from 1999 showing a level 12 warrior hitting more than missing? Anything? Nobody's doubting your word that your 12 war can't hit shit. What they are doubting is the claim that it's not classic.

I specifically remember making the choice NOT to play a melee because of this very issue in live classic. Kudos to those who could stick with it, but I'm not one of them.