View Single Post
  #16  
Old 03-19-2012, 08:20 AM
falkun falkun is offline
Planar Protector

falkun's Avatar

Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Ruins of Old Sebilis
Posts: 2,463
Default

This is how attempts at server rotations go:
http://www.project1999.org/forums/sh...ad.php?t=66783

Started as a serious thread in Server Chat, quickly ridden into the RnF cesspool.

However, here is the response received from leadership of one of the guilds polled for the rotation prior to the post moving to RnF:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Frieza_Prexus [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Rotations are generally created when it is in the rotating guild’s interests to do so. Very rarely, if ever, are they fully motivated by altruism. Each guild will zealously look out for its own interests as it should. TMO needs a lot of teeth still, and this is probably the biggest reason we’re not currently overly interested in a rotation. Notice that TMO only began rotating with IB when it was getting roughly half or slightly more of the Traks.

It’s decision theory. That said, eventually TMO would probably agree to a rotation when it appears in the guild’s interests. TMO is, overall, interested in being a reasonable and valuable portion of the community. But, the first responsibility is to the membership. While I appreciate the idea of an open slot on the rotation, accepting that when so many members still need teeth and other drops, would violate the duty the guild owes its members.

In regards to the quotes of Zeelot from Coldblooded, I meant to say in my original post that “I don’t think VD reached out BEFORE the training and such began a week or two ago.” I used the idea of “good faith” negotiation in my post. Please try to understand that, from TMO’s perspective, trying to negotiate right now in light of the VP activities is probably not going to feel like good faith. To TMO at least. That said, I’ll relegate that discussion to that thread.

EDIT: Ragefire was agreed to and respected. Yes, we had people in the lair. There was significant and heated debate within the guild, and the efforts to persuade others to respect the Ragefire rotation were immense and contentious. Please don't bring that us here as it will add nothing. TMO has decided to respect that. Please don't undo the difficult work it took to ensure that. Thank you.

To both TMO and VD in this thread, whatever we might feel is true and justified, or the right thing to say, let's use a bit of judgment before we say anything we KNOW will provoke the other side. Right or wrong, this is not the place to hash out our grievances.
Basically, as long as it is in the best interest of TMO, do not expect to see a rotation for specifically Trakanon, but I don't think its a huge stretch that this philosophy applies to all raid targets in TMO's sights. Now, the rest of this server can attempt to set up server rotations, but excluding one of the two top poop-socking guilds on this server will not please their members, who "still need teeth and other drops [in order to not] violate the duty [TMO] still owes its members."