Ouch that stinks. I didn't know about having to log both accounts in before the IP exemptions were given either, until someone in game mentioned it.
My brother and his wife waited since the 18th of Feb for thier exemptions and when I heard about the accounts needing to be logged in, I immediately called him and told him.
Now, had I not, he too would have missed this exemption yesterday because his wife will not play without him by her side. She had no intention on logging in and creating a char and playing without having him playing with her.
I suppose in your situation, I'd reapply for the exemption under the bugs/exploits just as you did before, now that you have the second account logged in and perhaps send an in game petition explaining that you were unaware that both accounts had to be logged in prior to the exemption being made ( even though both accounts were created)
Even under bugs and exploits thread you can petition there under OTHER and explain there as well.
I really don't know what to tell you
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]