Quote:
Originally Posted by Rogean
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
If you are asking for my personal opinion than I can oblige. I absolutely do not think the first kills were legitimate.
The keyword here is that it is my opinion.. my opinion alone does not give me what is necessary to take action on, which is a completely different situation. Just like a Judge may have an opinion about someone, may even talk down to them in court and say they were in the wrong, but in the end they ultimately have to prove without a doubt they were guilty to convict them.
You look at an encounter log like that and say, there's no way they could have killed nagafen with the number of players and the gear and char levels.. I look at it and consider the same thing and it pains me that I wasn't there to see it so that I could have the ammunition I would need to take action on it.
|
Absolutely.
No one is going to say that the first two Nagafen kills were "legitimate". What has been said is that the encounter bugged out was reported. Server was patched and it was assumed Nagafen had been fixed but it bugged out again.
Holocaust intentionally bugged the encounter the third and fourth times and was banned for being caught the fourth time.
Knowing that the encounter was/could be bugged should have been an indicator to engage this mob with caution. However caution was not taken and now you have this...
I would add that while Rogean made a decision to disband Holocaust for this I do not agree with it...but it is not MY decision to make. I only have to accept it (gladly i might add). Ranting about it over and over is not going to make him REVERSE his decision.