Are you still lower level?
BS damage has such a HUGE range of damage it can cause, I wouldn't worry too much about it. I have the Slime Coated Harpoon, at level 10 I BS'd for like 86, now at level 19 my hardest hit is 126... Thats with really low end twink gear, I think I spent around 3k total. I have 175 str unbuffed as a dwarf. I BS'd multiple times tonight, for around 20, with a level 40 druid STR buff. And my average BS damage is around 70-85 more or less.
So I'd say if you go with the other weapon your BS damage is going to average out really close to the same, since there is such a massive range of damages that it can deal. I'd goes with the Slime Coated Harpoon.
As far as regular hits, if you have higher STR or have STR buff, etc, etc... You will be hitting pretty hard with the harpoon. Even at level 10 my weapon was dealing more than x2 weapon damage from auto swings, and now that I'm level 19 I've seen it hit for 32 a few times.
|