No classic server had pvp xp gain. 
 
So far as EQ emu projects are considered, the most classic have the highest populations.  Say what you will.  The whole purpose of creating all of this stuff as it was before Luclin (or even Velious right now) is to entice people with a classic experience.  Why try and revert everything back the way it was if not for this purpose?   
 
EQ clearly has a nostalgaic following greater than any MMO.  Population-wise this is where you need to cash in.  What is going to keep people around is things being like they remember, in every little way possible.  I recently got a friend playing 99 blue, he walked around saying "oh I remember this!", which is what stood out from his experience more than anything... things being *like they were*. 
		
		
		
		
		
		
		 |