[Mardur]

I like item loot, but it has 2 serious consequences:

1) Lower population
2) MQ advantage

What I mean by #2, is that players that run MQ have an advantage on item loot servers. Not only do they have an advantage in general, but it's way too easy to hit a hot button and automagically have all your droppable gear bagged. Essentially what this becomes is no item loot for those running MQ and item loot for everyone else.

So I begrudgingly vote No. Coin loot - yes. Exp loss - no.

Edit: Altergate kind of solved #2 with an interesting system, though. A modified Altergate system where on death your loot window shows 8 random items, including bagged and your killer can choose one of those 8, would be pretty cool. The only problem is that classic purists wouldn't go for it.