There isn't a single way of doing this that will please everyone. Part of the fun for some is the drama, the adrenaline rush and the griefing that comes with the current method. It's a viable way of doing it no doubt, but that's just it, it makes for a lot of drama, in addition to alot of GM effort and intervention. Personally I'd prefer they didn't have to spend much time on this and bent there focus towards making this place as classic as possible and getting the work done for future content.
The other way is to show a little bit of maturity, some common sense, and just an inkling of decency. Let Gothic or Sapienta or whomever isn't "uber" have a shot at these. If they fail at it, the second guild gets a wack at it....if they weren't around because they assumed guild number 1 had it handled, the 3rd guild gets a chance at it. If all of those fail, its FFA on that particular mob/raid.
The problem with this is that it doesn't appeal much to the overly aggresive and competitive fuck tards who install truck nuts on there used F250's irl.
/gate
|