Bronson, it was a bit backwards from the beginning, but i disagree with on some points.
To justify a guild-wide punishment you need to show proof that it was done with the entire guild there and they benefited in a competitive scenario against another guild. Like when koota was hacking, for example. He tracked via SEQ, uthgaard set up a sting operation (i think it was uth?) and the guild benefited. A 2 week raid suspension is understandable considering the circumstances. When one of their members got caught MQing in lguk, though, didn't warrant a guild-wide raid suspension because the guild didn't benefit.
The same should apply here. Perun was caught SEQing in a raid scenario where his guild benefited and thus they deserve a 2 week suspension.
What should be taken into account, though, is that if Durison got nicked for training the rules should apply here as well, but the punishment not as harsh. Training another guild at a raid means your guild benefits and i think would consequently justify a guild-wide raid suspension, but certainly not for 2 weeks.
When a guild member cheats via SEQ/MQ they should be permabanned, no questions asked. If that guild benefited from those cheats then they too get a raid suspension. But if a member cheats, trains, dupes for his own benefit then i can't see why an entire guild would be punished, nevermind every single raiding guild on the server.
|