View Single Post
  #117  
Old 08-30-2011, 04:29 PM
G13 G13 is offline
Banned


Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 898
Default

Quote:
Nevertheless, the argument is somewhat hamstrung by the fact that an officer was suspended, which also makes it more difficult to claim ignorance of the impropriety. However, the fact remains that you cannot control the actions of others and I certainly do not support the idea that one guild or one person should be condemned because they associated with someone who was caught cheating. Could they be be condemend? Sure, it's all contextual. Should the cheaters be condemend: absolutely. But, the son does not inherit the sins of the father, if you will. And, I subscribe to the belief that you need more evidence than mere association in order to condemn.
In all honesty it's not fair to label all of TR cheaters as a result of Perun's actions, but at the same time Xzerion did state that TR/IB does not tolerate cheaters and will report them. So while the regular member is not responsible, their leadership is wouldn't you agree? A lot of their success as a guild can be attributed to Perun. It's like a professional athlete abusing steroids. As one of their monks/trackers/pullers his cheating had a direct effect on the overall success of his guild in terms of competition against competing guilds.

Would you agree that their achievements as a guild have been tarnished by this? If I was a member of TR I would furious at the officer core at the moment. This is a serious breach of trust.

If that's the case, shouldn't the guild as a whole be giving their leadership a vote of no confidence and be looking to replace it?