Quote:
Originally Posted by Zuranthium
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Your "point" is wrong. Twig did out DPS every other 1H weapon in the game at the time, with the mechanics that were in the game at the time. Hence why people in top raid guilds at the time were complaining about it. They changed the damage formula at some point after Kunark release.
|
I am not sure why you keep doing this. The reality is this thread is talking about Mosscovered Twig on P99. My calculator shows that Twig does not out-DPS other 1h weapons on P99 like Epic Fist or Addy Club, unless you are fighting a high AC target. This is using it in your primary hand. Thus far you have no P99 parses to prove otherwise.
Is it possible Twig was the best 1h weapon on live when it came out? Maybe. I doubt you have solid enough evidence for this claim either way. The data from back then is not very reliable, and it isn't really relevant to OP's question on P99.
If you can find some patch notes or a dev talkimg about it, that would be great! Learning EQ history is always fun.