[loramin]

I'm saying you were both wrong. Period, full stop.

They edited the wiki with their opinions, without getting consensus from the community or trying to make those edits work for the community. You just blindly undid their edits, instead of trying to incorporate them into the page in a way that works for both of you.

Again, the right way to edit the wiki is to think "what would be good for everyone reading this?" and make that change. No one involved did that, so you all failed.