Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimjam
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Some of you arguments don’t follow through.
Maybe FSI is the best for a torp shaman, but some of the points you make fail to argue that.
|
I disagree, and simply claiming this is not a good enough argument by itself. If you want to show that my points are incorrect, you need to back it up with something other than your opinion that I am wrong.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimjam
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
For example: Admitting regen isn’t necessary on a torp shaman is not the same as admitting fsi is best - neither are needed on a torp shaman!
|
Agreed. I never said "admitting regen isn't necessary means FSI is the best". I also agree neither are necessary. I am pointing out that Troxx agrees regen isn't necessary, which means Troxx cannot make the argument "Regen is necessary and FSI isn't".
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimjam
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
I think this is a detail you are overlooking - you seem to assume that posters who discuss your position of FSI are doing to support other racials as ‘best’ (and in some cases those posters may be doing so) but in many cases other posters don’t really have a favourite, they are just pointing out flaws in your arguments and you are pigeon holing them into being regen simps (I know you have done so to me in the past).
|
People are indeed trying to make factual claims about which racial is better. I have no problem with people saying "I prefer Regen over FSI". That is a completely valid opinion to have. But once you try to make a factual claim that Regen is better than FSI, you need to back it up. FSI is objectively the best racial when looking at the facts thus far. If someone wants to prove otherwise, they need to provide evidence to counter my evidence.
I think the real issue is people are afraid of finalizing these kinds of discussions with facts and evidence, because that means there will be less to talk about on the forums. I think a lot of people prefer to shoot the shit with random information and don't really care if it is true. I like shooting the shit too, but the Class Discussions section is specifically designed to answer questions about classes in a factual manner. There are other areas on this forum to shoot the shit.