I'm thinking a rebranding. That worked a lot on blue. A quick glance at the synonym approach:
<Walrus Cadre>
<Otter Gang>
<Sea Lion Bunch>
Or maybe something reflecting the evolution of events. If your guild gets spanked for not sharing maybe something like:
<Defiant>
<Problem Child> (90's nostalgia ftw)
At any rate, I'm here to help.