Woodsman's has the better ratio. Personally I'd prefer a weapon with stats that another class could use later, like Jade Inlaid Crescent Axe. I don't like that Woodsman's is Ranger only, as it's a hard resell later.
Your 1hers are fine, lots of weapons are good for that role:
Jagged Blade of Mourning
Sarnak Backstabber
Jade Mace
Lamentation
Lupine Dagger
Etc, etc.
|