Pre-nerf Red Wood Wands were also classic
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
This is the "You can't prove your point 100%, so the opposite must be true (which just so happens to be my opinion."
Sure, it's logical to assume people on forums will not be a 100% match with the server demographics. So, what? Are you making any positive claims about demographics you can back up with numbers?
Why is your assumption more likely than the opposite assumption? It's not. If every player were forced to vote on login, we might see the 72-28 hold, or the spread get even bigger.
It's logical to assume that both numbers would increase. This means there will be more interest in a Teal server than the current 455 players. You don't know that there are more or less pro-Teal players that haven't voted yet than anti-Teal.
What we know for sure so far: from one, non-stickied, non-official thread on one-sub forum on project1999.com there are 455 players who want Teal reopened, and hundreds of players who haven't haven't voted yet. Most people would conclude this is a big chunk of the playerbase worth considering.
My suggestion: Devs give a response with reasoning, or open up an official poll for players to vote on.