Remember in that other thread when I told you you were so incredibly wrong about this and you disagreed?
https://www.project1999.com/forums/s...&postcount=396
https://www.project1999.com/forums/s...&postcount=397
I hope you have changed your mind. Not only have you tried to bring entirely new mechanics into Classic Everquest, but you've tried to bring mechanics from modern MMOs to a community and game that generally has distaste for those mechanics. People didn't come here to play World of Warcraft or Guild Wars 2 (except you it seems).
Yes, I am telling you here and now, that most of these Everquest players would rather have the current List system rather than a modern Participation Trophy system. If you cannot comprehend that, then you don't comprehend Classic Everquest or old school MMOs in general.
Your suggestions also removes guilds competing for end-game mobs, which is basically all end-game even is on Everquest.
I just... I just don't get it. You have tried to completely and utterly change the foundation and spirit of Everquest in just a few paragraphs and I am truly astonished right now. Everquest is a TWENTY year old game that is still running official servers and the mechanics of loot and raiding on Live ARE STILL THE SAME TODAY.