All the speculation about CHA in these chanter charming guides is basically useless, nobody was doing any objective testing until people started doing it in those links I posted earlier. It's all feels and old wives tales and people believing their own superstitious nonsense. The effect on charm was tiny and got lost in the noise.
(There was good evidence for an effect on mez, but that's not the issue here.)
Tashan always had a big impact though and it's plain to see in the testing done back then. The effect of MR on charm breaks was massive.
I'd love to swing the nerf bat at chanters but so far I haven't seen classic evidence to justify it, or where you would even swing it. The mechanics on p99 are pretty faithful to classic it seems?
|