No matter how hard we try, no matter what limitations we deliberately patch back into the game, being able to truly relive the classic experience of playing EQ for the first time in 1999 is an unachievable goal. We've already ventured into every nook and cranny of Norrath, so the sense of exploring the unexplored is gone. Even for any potential newcomers that have never played EQ, they have still undoubtedly played more modern MMOs, and having done so will influence and spoil how they regard classic EQ.
The loss of quality of life features (pet windows, better UIs, not having to stare at a spellbook while meditating, etc.) and the inclusion of poor design rules (class XP penalties) do not equate to a classic experience. Having them in the game will not make the Green server more enjoyable, and for many people their inclusion will make them enjoy it a lot less.
So, to answer the question: How classic do I want it?
Personally, I just want a fresh start on a new server, and I feel that this is by far the most classic potential of the Green server. However, if I'm forced to stare at the spellbook while meditating, then I'll pass on Green because, for me, there's a point where such limitations rob the game of its entertainment... but that's okay. This isn't my project, and I'm not the one making the decisions.
|