2h: Butcherblock Hammer
1h: Essence Blade or Jeldorin?
Idk, I feel like damage output isn't as important as damage prevention/negation for Paladins, but that's a long-held bias and could be wrong. If going the damage route, others who have looted it also insisted on the Sledge of Smashing. Looking over the list, it does seem like the most solid all-around option for the slot.
Buckler of Insight has to be the best, unless The Qeynos Shield drops on here at some point, but even then. Shield of the Dawn and the Protector are about tied for second place.
|