Quote:
Originally Posted by Atmas
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
The list is already supposed to be people sitting at the camp. If you leave you should be off the list.
If you randomly hand off what would discourage people from just strolling up at the start of the window? I think it really has to just be hand off in order of who has been waiting there the longest.
|
I'm not against that, but the problem there is that it allows the current camper to lie about the list if they're dishonest, and even if they're honest it forces them to maintain a list.
I'm looking for the most fair system overall, while also being as simple as possible. If a lucky person (who had an equal chance as everyone else) shows up just in time to random vs. someone who was waiting, that seems like far less of a problem to me than someone having the ability to lock down a camp with their friends, or forcing everyone who does a busy camp to have to write down lists of whos next (and then get into camp fight drama when someone disagrees about list order).
"Everyone present randoms" is fair and simple and there's never any drama because it's always clear who's present.