[Rygar]

Basically the only advantage the monk has is FD, being able to take hits better, and disciplines. If you start factoring soulfires and puppet strings and stuff, it just gets stupid IMO.

Without any clickies whatsoever, I'd say Shaman has the greatest chance at success (but slowest), then Enchanter, then Monk.

Free access to all high end clickies it is probably the same, but monk shines a bit brighter. I can't imagine for the life of me a mob that a monk can kill with puppet strings and soulfire that a shaman can't kill with puppet strings and soulfire (nevermind they have torpor).

In regards to tash stick, it can be used to debuff on solo challenge for sure. Guildie of mine used tash sticks + whirlwind discipline to get a tash off luckily, then slowstone on Guardian Kozzalym in Western Wastes. Used 9 charges of wort pots or something like that (he also has Fist of Nature, so... yea).