Every other server out there, live and emu, goes beyond Velious. Anyone who wants to play beyond Velious has LOTS of options. No problem with that.
What is so wrong with ONE server (maybe someday even 2 or 3!) stopping at Velious, which the majority of players agree was the last GREAT expansion to Everquest?
My guess is that if this server ever DID
jump the shark (which I am confident that it won't), then another server would crop up. Again it would have the goal of stopping at Velious. Would people then go join that server and lobby for it, too, to go beyond Velious?
Why isn't it OKAY for one classic server to exist?