See? You are literally arguing semantics.
I've got an example of AG clearing island 1. You want to focus in on the word "clearing" and not accept that AG did it. You cannot undo it, and no amount of wordsmithing is going to make it disappear.
But they didn't finish! When they started, they had clear intent to finish. But it was a regular member and not an officer! Regular members are still members of the guild (
except for Aftermath "alts" according to AM members) and need to consider how their actions reflect on the guild tag. But it was just that one time! It's still a valid example.
I don't care about your excuses. Just like I don't care about your OoA agreement.