It seems the basis of the problem here is Cylock doesn't have any idea how things have been done in the past and thus is making calls based on the letter of the law without regard to our elf law version of jurisprudence.
That is how Red Dawn was forced to eat YT to force LNS, because the rules simply say "died". Later this was reinterpreted to just mean the force "lost".
With no regard to the past ruling that pelling in range of at least person in the raid force is allowed; he just read the rules and took them literally.
We're adaptive people we can deal with rule changes but we were given NO NOTICE and ate character suspensions based on a rule change we had no idea happened.
Sirken could have cleared everything up by tossing out some warnings and posting a rule clarification instead he just moved the appeals to resolved.
|